Home › New York › Amsterdam › Pool Prodigy

Pool Prodigy Pool hall in Amsterdam, NY

4.5★★★★★ 186 Google reviews

15 tablesDiamond tablesOpen late

Visit

35 E Main St
Amsterdam, NY 12010

Call (518) 728-3100

Directions poolprodigyhall.com

Monday5 PM – 11 PM
Tuesday5 PM – 12 AM
Wednesday5 PM – 11 PM
Thursday5 PM – 12 AM
Friday5 PM – 1 AM
Saturday5 PM – 12 AM
Sunday4 PM – 11 PM

Hours from Google, shown in local time. Confirm before you go.

Call ahead for table rates.

Fact sheet

Kind Pool hall Google lists it as a pool hall
Google rating 4.5 ★
Reviews 186
Tables 15 tables per its website

Pool Prodigy is a pool hall at 35 E Main St, Amsterdam, NY. It has a 4.5-star rating from 186 Google reviews. It has 15 tables, per its website.

What the reviews and website show

Each item is listed only with its proof: a sentence from a 4- or 5-star Google review, the place's own website, or how often reviews mention it.

  • Diamond tables

    Per the place's website.

  • Full bar

    “Full bar, great food, and kitchen stays open until close.”— from a Google review

    Mentioned 5 times in reviews · also per the place's website.

  • Food

    “Clean, brightly lit, amazing staff, decent food, decent music (nothing vulgar.) My husband and I went here for a night out with our teenagers and some friends on a Friday night.”— from a Google review

    Mentioned 38 times in reviews · also per the place's website.

  • Open late

    Per its Google hours: open past midnight 1 night a week (latest close 1 AM).

What players say

Nice atmosphere. The bartenders are friendly and attentive. It's like going to a place like Cheers. The food is consistently consistent. I had a Buffalo chicken wrap with fries and everything was wonderful as usual. The fries were nice and hot. My chicken wrap was fresh and the chicken was warm and perfectly spiced.

★★★★★ Christine, Apr 2022

Food was great, it has pool tables it was just frustrating waiting for table to play there. But food was amazing!!!! P.s sorry I meant to give 5 star and let ppl be aware of await time, Thank you for replying

★★★★★ Diz, Apr 2026

Former review was for former owners. New owners are much more ambitious bigger atmosphere and great place to hang! Disregard first review it was 7 years ago and can't be edited!

★★★★★ Adam, Feb 2026

Oh my God, let me start with just the food. It’s amazing. It’s delicious. It’s not dry. It’s really good. I’m gonna have some pictures here for people if you are looking for a good time and a nice bar this is a place to be watch Sully from Soli exploring town and I love this one.

★★★★★ Sullymar, Jul 2026

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 186 on Google →

Where to find Pool Prodigy

Pool halls and bars with pool tables nearby

Under a mile away

14.9 miles away

Clinton Street Pub

Schenectady, NY · bar with pool tables

4.2★★★★ 165 reviews
Open late
159 Clinton St #2016

15.4 miles away

Fritz's Taproom

Schenectady, NY

4.4★★★★ 249 reviews
6 tables per a review TournamentsOpen late
1913 Hamburg St

16.8 miles away

Maloney's Pub

Schenectady, NY · bar with pool tables

4.4★★★★ 111 reviews
APA league
1325 State St

16.8 miles away

17.0 miles away

Both places to play pool in Amsterdam, NY →

Pool in nearby towns

All pool halls in New York →

Something out of date? Send a correction. Own this place? Update your listing. It's free.

Independent listing, not affiliated with this place or with any league organization. Details come from public business info, customer reviews and the place's own website. Call ahead to confirm hours, table rates and league nights before you go.