Home › New York › Bay Shore › The Penny Pub

The Penny Pub Bar with pool tables in Bay Shore, NY

4.4★★★★☆ 401 Google reviews

DartsOpen late

Pool tables

“they have a section in the back of the bar were we played pool, darts, huge jinga listened to great music..”— from a Google review

Pool comes up 3 times in its reviews.

Visit

79 W Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706

Call (631) 969-4061

Directions thepennypub.com

Monday12 PM – 3 AM
Tuesday12 PM – 3 AM
Wednesday12 PM – 3 AM
Thursday12 PM – 3 AM
Friday12 PM – 3 AM
Saturday12 PM – 3 AM
Sunday12 PM – 3 AM

Hours from Google, shown in local time. Confirm before you go.

Call ahead for table rates.

Fact sheet

Kind Bar with pool tables Google category: Irish pub
Google rating 4.4 ★
Reviews 401
The Penny Pub, bar with pool tables in Bay Shore, NY
Customer photo 2 of The Penny Pub
Customer photo 3 of The Penny Pub
Customer photo 4 of The Penny Pub
Customer photo 5 of The Penny Pub

The Penny Pub is an irish pub at 79 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY. It is listed here because its customer reviews show it has pool tables. It has a 4.4-star rating from 401 Google reviews.

What the reviews and website show

Each item is listed only with its proof: a sentence from a 4- or 5-star Google review, the place's own website, or how often reviews mention it.

  • Darts

    Per the review quoted above · mentioned 4 times in reviews.

    Pool and darts in New York →

  • Full bar

    “It’s rare to walk into a bar and feel better when you leave, not just because of the drinks, but because someone actually made the effort to connect.”— from a Google review

    Mentioned 20 times in reviews.

    Pool with a full bar in New York →

  • Food

    “All of the bartenders I've had are nice and quick at getting your food orders in and keeping your drinks full.”— from a Google review

    Mentioned 23 times in reviews.

    Pool and food in New York →

  • Open late

    Per its Google hours: open past midnight 7 nights a week (latest close 3 AM).

    Pool open late in New York →

What players say

Everyone treats you like family here. It’s such a welcoming place. Everyone from Mike, gabby, Colleen, all the amazing staff and bouncers. Theirs a pool table in the back and they even have a dart league. Two dart areas. Always a good time and good vibe.

★★★★★ Martin, Jan 2025

This bar was a blast to visit we rolled in from Philadelphia with 12 guys after a local event we came up for ended.. bartenders and locals were friendly. We had great service and mixed drink were well made. Beer's were ice cold and poured the way they should be..

★★★★★ Dan, Jul 2023

Sean Is the Heart of The Penny Pub After a tough day, I walked into The Penny Pub in Bay Shore just looking for a place to decompress. What I found was more than just a great local spot—it was a reminder that good people make all the difference.

★★★★★ Anthony, Sep 2025

I stopped in for a couple of Guinnesses and something to eat. Decided on the Irish Grilled Cheese and waffle fries. The grilled cheese was good. Not great. The fries were great. The Guinness was good and the service attentive.

★★★★☆ Jude, Jan 2026

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 401 on Google →

Where to find The Penny Pub

Pool halls and bars with pool tables nearby

Under a mile away

Cork and Bull

East Islip, NY · bar with pool tables

4.9★★★★★ 41 reviews
DartsOpen late
259 Carleton Ave

3.3 miles away

4.0 miles away

Sea Breeze

Babylon, NY · bar with pool tables

4.1★★★★ 121 reviews
Open late
470 Fire Island Ave

4.3 miles away

50 Yard Line Sports Bar

West Babylon, NY · bar with pool tables

4.4★★★★ 127 reviews
DartsOpen late
371 Little East Neck Rd

5.0 miles away

Sidelines Cafe

Lindenhurst, NY · bar with pool tables

4.1★★★★ 143 reviews
DartsOpen late
43 W Hoffman Ave

7.0 miles away

Both places to play pool in Bay Shore, NY →Bars with pool tables in New York →

Pool in nearby towns

All pool halls in New York →

Something out of date? Send a correction. Own this place? Update your listing. It's free.

Independent listing, not affiliated with this place or with any league organization. Details come from public business info, customer reviews and the place's own website. Call ahead to confirm hours, table rates and league nights before you go.